Confessions Of An Enneagram Type 3 Pastor


I was sitting with a pastor friend of mine the other day and we were both talking about how our enneagram personality types (which are different) were absolutely terrible. I think that is pretty common. All of the enneagram types have beauty and brokenness, but many times it is hard to see anything but the gross stuff when you look at your own type. I am 100% guilty of this. 

As the title suggests, yes, I am a 3. If you don’t know about the 3, here are a few highlights. 

-People of this personality type need to be validated in order to feel worthy; they pursue success and want to be admired.

- while Threes do tend to succeed in whatever realm they focus their energies, they are often secretly afraid of being or becoming "losers."

- Threes can sometimes find intimacy difficult. Their need to be validated for their image often hides a deep sense of shame about who they really are, a shame they unconsciously fear will be unmasked if another gets too close.

- Because it is central to the type Three fixation to require external validation, Threes often, consciously and unconsciously, attempt to embody the image of success that is promoted by their culture. Threes get in trouble when they confuse true happiness, which depends on inner states, with the image of happiness which society has promoted.

- Threes, who generally appear quite happy, often hide a deeply felt sense of meaninglessness. The attainment of the image never quite satisfies.

There are many other characteristics of a 3 and also more ‘positive’ things you can find, but I didn’t really focus on those when I read about a 3, in fact, that is exactly where I found myself. 

My entire church staff was going through the book The Road Back To You: An Enneagram Journey To Self-Discovery and there was much conversation in the office about each personality type. I already had a pretty basic understanding of the enneagram as a whole and of my specific type before we started the book but I was excited to learn more. I was proud of the fact that I was a 3 and to be honest thought a 3 was hands down the best type. But then I begin to read more about it. 

The chapter in the book on the 3 begin to describe some of the characteristics and as I read I couldn’t help but realize they seemed predominantly negative. Many of the examples used were of people who were really broken, and a bit ‘slimy’ if you know what I mean. They just seemed like pretty messed up people. At first I started getting mad that I wasn’t hearing about how great I was, and was only being represented by all of the negative things. In fact, many of the ‘positive’ things were followed up by explaining how they were really just a mask for something negative that was truly who 3’s are. For a few days I was mad about it until I realized the reason I was so upset was because all of the negative things said about my personality type in the book were so incredibly true about me, I realized I really was a terrible person. 

It hit me like a ton of bricks, I sucked. I hated my personality and how I was wired. I burst into my boss, a fellow pastor and fellow 3’s office, and plopped down on his couch with the book outstretched toward him and simply stated, “dude, we suck!” He laughed, and then listened to my reasoning as I explained how our personality came with so much negative baggage and it was all true in my life! He slowly tried to offer some words of encouragement as he too was still processing what I had said. I was still stewing in my realization and I didn’t really listen to what he had to say before I went on my way. 

The very next week, while I was still wrestling with how terrible of a person I was simply because of my personality type I was speaking at a summer camp. I was overjoyed to be able to share Jesus with hundreds of students and leaders and it was going great! I had just walked off stage from one of the most passionate messages I have ever preached. I was on fire (not literally), running around the stage and yelling “let’s gooooo” as over 90% of the room was standing to indicate they had made a decision for Christ that night. I walked straight off the stage and out the side doors to the waiting balcony where I could be by myself and process what I had just witnessed and been a part of. 

I was completely overwhelmed with what God had done, and I knew it was all Him, but as I stood out there I couldn’t help hearing the small voice inside that wanted recognition for the excellent message I had delivered. I quickly tried to silence it by praying and thanking God for what He had done that night but as I stood out on that balcony in a moment of ‘humility’ while the worship music blared from inside the chapel and the sound of hundreds of people praising God poured out the open doors in front of me I thought to myself, “I hope someone sees me right now and admires how humble I am as I bow in prayer focusing on God.” 

Isn’t that sickening? Even in that sacred moment I could only think about myself, my image, and how awesome I looked to the people around me. In that moment I too realized how sickening it was, and I was disgusted with myself. My joy and pride turned quickly to anger, and hatred of myself at how much of a mess I was and how jacked up my personality type is. I hated my Threeness. I just wanted to escape myself and my own personality. I knew I needed to really get away where people could not see me and I would not be tempted to make it all about my image. I found an empty room and cried out to God, asking Him why He would give me this personality type and how I was supposed to live with how much of a rotten person I was. 

As I sat in that room with thoughts of the enneagram book, my understanding of how a 3 worked, the situation that just happened, and my new-found realization that I hated how I was wired, that is when I heard God speak. It wasn’t audible, but it was a prayer I begin to hear in my head over and over. I wanted to pray ‘God change my personality type’ but instead what I heard was, “God, make me less of me and more of You.” 

It metaphorically smacked me in the face, God was saying-- I wired you. I made you a 3. I designed you exactly how I wanted you and there are so many beautiful things about your Threeness. But the problem comes when you become more of you and less of Me instead of more of Me and less of you.

My personality type was/is not the problem. The problem comes when I become more of me and less of Him. Each personality type within the enneagram is extremely beautiful, but it can also be very broken. Our part in it is all the same, to strive to become more like Christ everyday and when we do we are able to unlock the beautiful things He has wired into each one of us. 

However, for those of you who are a 3, here are a few intentional things I am working on doing to get ahead of my Threeness and curb the potential pitfalls I may succumb to.  

As a 3 and especially as a 3 who is a pastor I need:

-To be Authentic.  To strive to be real and take off the mask I often find myself putting on to show those around me what I want them to see. For me this begins by having people in my life I can tell the dark, gross thoughts and feelings I have to.  By having people in my life I can be honest with about the exact account I just recounted as soon as it happened I am already peeling off the mask and getting beyond the fakeness I feel. 

-To find Accountability. I continue to strive to be authentic, but I also need people who will check up on me and keep me accountable. I know I can count on my wife to call me out when my Threeness becomes unhealthy, and I know I can count on some of my close friends to ask me tough questions and check in on me often to see how my heart is. 

-To operate out of an overflow. When I fail to be in Christ and try to operate apart from Him I continuously find myself in a very unhealthy place. 

-To continuously pray. A constant reminder to be “more of Him and less of me” is 100% necessary for me at all times. This short and simple prayer reminds me, and helps keep me on track. 


I am 100% a work in progress as I figure out how to balance my flesh and my identity in Christ as well as my personality and my calling as a pastor. Hopefully some of my experience can help you on your journey as well. What are some of the difficulties you have encountered and how have you combated them? 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Leaders Are... Passionate About Creating A Learning Culture (Part 5)

Leaders Are... Willing To Go The Extra Mile (Part 6)

Leading Leaders: The 4 Things Your Leaders Need